Skip to main content
University of Pittsburgh logo
Department of Psychiatry
University of Pittsburgh logo
Information for You
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Prospective Trainees
  • Investigators
  • Patients & Families
Our People
Menu
  • Education
    • Education Overview
    • Residency & Fellowships
    • Research Training
    • Medical Student Education
    • Clinical Psychology Internship
    • Clinician Career Development
  • Research
    • Research Overview
    • Research Faculty
    • Research Training
    • Investigator Resources
    • Health Equity Research
    • Participate in Research
  • Patient Care
    • Patient Care Overview
    • Access to Care
    • Clinical Services Overview
    • Clinical Faculty
    • Resources for Clinicians
  • Community & Culture
    • Community & Culture Overview
    • Leadership & Advisory Council
    • Research Equity & Community Health
    • Community & Partnership
    • Community News
    • Community Awards & Accolades
  • About Us
    • About Us Overview
    • Chair's Message
    • Our People
    • Our History, Our Present, & Our Future
    • Life in Pittsburgh
  • News & Events
    • News & Events Overview
    • News
    • Events
  • Information for You
    • Faculty & Staff
    • Prospective Trainees
    • Investigators
    • Patients & Families
  • Our People

Main menu

  • Education
    • Residency & Fellowships
      • Residency Training
      • Training Pathways & Concentrations
      • Clinical Fellowships
      • Our Clinical Learning Environment
      • Our Leadership
      • Our Chief Residents
      • Our Residents
    • Research Training
      • Undergraduate & Graduate Student Training
      • Medical Student Research
      • Research During Residency
      • Postdoctoral Training
      • Medical Student Education
      • Clinical Psychology Internship
      • Clinician Career Development
  • Research
    • Research Training
      • Undergraduate & Graduate
      • Medical Student Research
      • Research During Residency
      • Postdoctoral Training
    • Investigator Resources
      • Research Day
      • Research Review Committee
      • Assessment Instruments
    • Health Equity Research
      • REACH Collaborative
      • Research Faculty
      • Participate in Research
  • Patient Care
      • Access to Care
      • Clinical Services Overview
      • Clinical Faculty
      • Resources for Clinicians
  • Community & Culture
      • Leadership & Advisory Council
      • Research Equity & Community Health
      • Community & Partnership
      • Community News
      • Community Awards & Accolades
  • About Us
    • Our People
      • Faculty
      • Staff
      • Emeritus Faculty
      • Chair's Message
      • Our History, Our Present, & Our Future
      • Life in Pittsburgh
  • News & Events
      • News
      • Events
  • Search

Breadcrumb menu

  1. Home
  2. News
  • July 14, 2020
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Bluesky
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Threads
  • Share via email

New Research in Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging—The Reliability of Model-Based Planning in Measuring Decision-Making Processes

Price & Colleagues Biological Psychiatry 2020

To identify neurocognitive mechanisms of mood and anxiety disorders, scientists are increasingly employing computational models to map latent decision-making processes onto dissociable neural substrates and clinical phenotypes. However, the reliability of measures used in research in this area up to now has been unclear.

In a study recently published in Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging, Pitt Psychiatry researchers including Rebecca Price, PhD, and postdoctoral scholar Vanessa Brown, PhD, assessed the reliability of computational models, focusing on model-based planning (which, prior research suggests, specifically relates to the transdiagnostic psychiatric symptom of compulsivity) to measure decision-making processes. Study participants in a primary sample comprised individuals between the ages of 18 to 55 with compulsive symptoms. Comparative data was drawn from three additional, publicly available datasets. Participants in the primary sample completed 100 trials of a two-step reward task. The investigators then used multiple techniques to remove problematic data before employing generative and non-generative model-based planning to assess how reward, and its interaction with transition type (progression through task stages, a measure of model-based planning), affected choice. 

“Linking neurocomputational models to clinical symptoms, such as showing how compulsivity is characterized by reduced model-based control, is needed to advance our understanding and treatment of psychiatric disorders,” said Dr. Brown, the study’s first author. “However, most methods used in this type of research vary from lab to lab and haven’t been systematically assessed for reliability.” 

The investigators studied whether model-based planning from a reinforcement learning task determines the best reliability—and if so, what methods will best achieve this reliability. Their findings confirmed the strength of these reliability measures for clinical research. 

“In this impressive set of analyses, Vanessa took on the behemoth task of thoroughly exploring the analysis choices that researchers make and systematically quantifying their impact on the reliability of a widely-used computational measure,” said senior author Dr. Price “This is something that researchers rarely take the time to do, but as Vanessa convincingly shows, it is absolutely essential to improving both the validity and the potential clinical impact of findings.”  

Improving the Reliability of Computational Analyses: Model-Based Planning and Its Relationship with Compulsivity
Brown VM, Chen J, Gillan CM, Price RB.

Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging Vol. 5, Issue 6, June 2020. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpsc.2019.12.019

University of Pittsburgh logo

Stay connected

  • LinkedIn
  • Bluesky
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Threads

Location

Thomas Detre Hall
3811 O'Hara Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15213
  • Contact Us

Related Websites

  • medschool.pitt.edu
  • pitt.edu

Explore

  • Find People
  • Education
  • Research
  • Patient Care
  • Community & Culture
  • About Us
  • News and Events

Information for

  • Faculty & Staff
  • Prospective Trainees
  • Investigators
  • Patients & Families

Intranet Sites

  • Psy Hub for faculty (requires UPMC log-in and UPMC computer or access through MyApps)
  • Postdoc Portal Postdoc Portal for postdoctoral trainees
  • Office of Grants and Contracts (OGC) website accessible on internal network only

Join Our Newsletter

Stay up to date on department and faculty happenings.

University of Pittsburgh Department of Psychiatry mailing list Fill in the form to subscribe to the mailing list.

Psychiatry Advances Podcast

Covering Innovative research and patient-centered programs.

Listen to Podcast

© 2026 University of Pittsburgh Department of Psychiatry